Optimization of Blank Holder Force to Control Wrinkling and Fracture of Cylindrical Cups in Deep Drawing

  ijett-book-cover  International Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology (IJETT)          
© 2012 by IJETT Journal
Volume-3 Issue-5                       
Year of Publication : 2012
Authors :  R. Venkat Reddy , Dr T.A. Janardhan Reddy , Dr.G.C.M. Reddy


R. Venkat Reddy , Dr T.A. Janardhan Reddy , Dr.G.C.M. Reddy. "Optimization of Blank Holder Force to Control Wrinkling and Fracture of Cylindrical Cups in Deep Drawing ". International Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology (IJETT). V3(5):669-676 Sep-Oct 2012. ISSN:2231-5381. www.ijettjournal.org. published by seventh sense research group


The Predominant failure modes in sheet metal parts (deep drawing process ) a re wrinkling , fracture. In many cases these defects may be eliminated by appropriate control of the blank holding force (BHF). This paper summarizes the results of a resent study on the formability of rectangular or cylindrical par ts from Extra Deep Draw (EDD) steels . Wrinkling , fracture limits have been determined and BHF control methods have been developed to eliminate defects, improve part quality, and increase the draw depth. The prediction and prevention of wrink l ing and fracture a re extremely important in the design of tooling and process parameters in deep drawing process. Forming process of Extra Deep Draw ( EDD ) Steel alloy sheets can be investigated by using deep drawing process. When the BHF is 70 - 80 N / m m 2 the steel sheets with a thickness 5 mm can be produced in the cups without any defects such as wrinkling, tea r ing. A 3 - D explicit - finite element analysis is used to investigate the influence of various BHF schemes on sheet metal formability limits especially wrinkling, and fracture. The ro le of relevant parameters of each blank holding technique is also investigated . Experiments were conducted using a die block of 250 mm diameter and punch 240 mm on EDD steel alloys of blank size is 165mm and thickness 5 mm.


[1] A. Wifi, A. Mosal l a m , “S ome aspects of BHF schemes in deep drawing process ” , journal of achievements in materials and manufacturing engineering Vol . 24 issue 1, 2007 , 315 - 320.
[2] M . M.Ismail, G.murali, Dr N .M Sheriff, Dr A. Rajadurai “ Experimental and Numerical Investigations on the forming characteristics of thin steel sheet in the presence of a rectangular d raw bead ” , journal of the Institution of Engineers (India), Vol 89, 2008 p.no. 17 - 24.
[3] E.J. Obermeyer, S.A. Maj le ssi, “ A revie w of recent advances in the application of BHF towards improving the forming limits of sheet metal parts ” , Journal of materials processing technology 75 (198) 222 - 234.
[4] Donaldson. “Tool Design’ Tata McGraw Hill Publication, New Delhi, 1976.
[5] Y.H . Chen, S.Y. Lee, and J.Y. Wang: Journal of material science technology, 2002 , 18 , 30 , p.no. 227.
[6] Siegert, K. , 1993, “CNC Hydraulic Multi point blank holder system for sheet metal forming presses”, Annals of the CIRP, Vol.42/1 pp. 319 - 322.
[7] Ahetoglu, M.A., Coremans, A., Kinzel, G.K., and Altan, T., 1993 , “Improving Drawability by using variable BHF and pressure in Deep Drawing of round and non - symmetric parts” SAE paper no. 930287, International congress, Detroit, Michigan.
[ 8 ] H. Gharib, A.S. Wifi, M. Younan, A. Nassef, “ Optimization of the BHF in cup drawing ” Journal of achievements in materials and manufacturing engineering Vol. 18, issue 1 - 2, 2006 .
[9] N.Kawai; (1961). “ Critical conditions Of wrinkling i n deep drawing of sheet Metals ”.Bulletion of JSME, 4,169 - 192.
[10 ] G.C.M.Reddy ,”Course material on AICTE/ISTE short term training programme on advanced metal working techniques and finite element simulations in metal forming.” July, 2003.
[11] L.Frantini “Numerical Analysis and experimental tests on deep drawing sequences”, IMechE, 1995 P.61 - 66 .
[12] Jamal Hematian “Finite Eiement Modeling of Wri nkling during Deep Drawing of Pressure Vessel End Closures (PVECs)” M.S.Thesis, Queen's University Kingston, Ontario, Canada , January 2000 .
[13] Xi Wang, Jian Cao, On the prediction of side wall wrinkling in sheet metal forming processes, International J ournal of Mechanical Sciences 42 (2000) 2369 - 2394 .
[14] Huang, A., Lowe, A., and Cardew - Hall, M. J., 2001, ‘‘Experimental Validation of Sheet Thickness Optimization for Super plastic Forming of Engineering Structures,’’ J. Mater. Process. Technol., 112 , pp. 136 – 143 .
[15] Kawai, N., Mori, T., Hayashi, H., and Kondoh, F., 1987, “Effects of Punch Cross - Section on Deep Drawability of square shell of aluminum sheet”
[16] Sommer , N ., 1986, “Blank Holder Force and Design of Blank Holders in Deep Drawing” ( in G erman , Ph.D. Dissertation, IFUm, University of Hannover, Germany.
[17] Murata, A ., Ebine, Y., and Matsui, M.S. 1992, “Effect of Blank Holding Force Control on Deep Drawability of Sq u are cups.

Blank Holder Force , Deep Drawing, EDD steel alloy, Wrinkling, Fracture.